A small, sourced directory
Refill the cylinder you already own.
Most grocery-store and hardware-store cages exchange your tank for a different one that was pre-filled somewhere else. A refill station puts propane into your cylinder and, by the gallon, charges you only for what it adds. This site lists those refill places, city by city.
Refill versus exchange, in plain terms
A cylinder sold as a “20 lb” tank is named for how much propane it can safely hold. The National Institute of Standards and Technology notes that although a 20 lb cylinder will safely hold 20 lb of propane, most 20 lb cylinders in exchange programs are filled and labeled to a net weight of 15 lb. [NIST]
Blue Rhino, a major exchange brand, states the same number in its own FAQ: “Blue Rhino propane grill tanks contain a net weight of 15 lbs. of propane.” [Blue Rhino]
A refill station sells liquid propane by the gallon and fills your cylinder, typically toward that 20 lb safe capacity, if the tank passes inspection and is still in date. Tractor Supply, which operates refill dispensers, says a typical 20 lb grill cylinder “holds approximately 4.6 gallons of Propane,” that you pay only for the amount used to refill it, and that “Refilling your tank is always a better deal than exchanging.” [Tractor Supply]
U-Haul’s location pages make a second, often-overlooked point: if you exchange a tank, you do not get credit for propane left in the one you turn in. [U-Haul] A 2022 NIST/NCWM national survey also found that a substantial share of customers returned exchange cylinders with propane still inside (about 25% returned more than 1 lb; about 8% returned more than 5 lb). [NIST survey]
Honest cost math (worked example)
We did not find a single official, posted in-store Charlotte exchange-cage price we could verify on November 18, 2026, so this page does not invent one. Delivery-only prices (for example Blue Rhino Delivery+) are not the same as a store-cage swap, so we do not use them here.
What we can do is price a refill using (1) Tractor Supply’s approximate 4.6 gallons for a 20 lb cylinder and (2) refill prices U-Haul itself posted on its Charlotte location pages on November 18, 2026. If an exchange fill is 15 lb, that is 15/20 of 4.6 gallons, or about 3.45 gallons of propane. Density varies a little with temperature; treat these as approximations, not lab measurements.
| What you’re buying | Approx. gallons | At $4.15/gal (lowest Charlotte U-Haul price we saw) | At $4.95/gal (highest Charlotte U-Haul price we saw) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 15 lb of propane (same net weight as a typical exchange tank) | ~3.45 gal | ~$14.32 + tax | ~$17.08 + tax |
| A typical 20 lb cylinder filled toward capacity | ~4.6 gal | ~$19.09 + tax | ~$22.77 + tax |
Sources: Tractor Supply “approximately 4.6 gallons” for a typical 20 lb cylinder; U-Haul Charlotte tank-refill prices of $4.15 and $4.95 per gallon plus tax, posted on official location pages on November 18, 2026 (America/Los_Angeles). Those U-Haul prices already differed by location and can change. Sales tax is not included. If your tank is not empty, a refill should cost less than a full-fill figure because you pay only for what is added.
How to use this if you only know an exchange price. Divide that flat exchange fee by 15 to get a rough price per pound, then compare it with the refill price per pound (refill $/gallon ÷ [20 lb ÷ 4.6 gal] ≈ refill $/gallon ÷ 4.35). If the exchange cage also takes a tank that still has gas in it, you paid for that leftover gas twice.
Before you drive over
- Check the date on the collar. The U.S. Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration says a propane cylinder must be requalified within 12 years of manufacture (and again on a 5-, 10-, or 12-year cycle after that, depending on the inspection mark). A station may refuse an overdue or damaged cylinder. [PHMSA]
- Store hours are not a guarantee that a certified attendant is standing at the tank, or that the dispenser has propane in it. Call, or check the location’s own page, before a special trip.
- Prices move. We publish a price only when an official page stated it on a dated check, and we tell you to verify it.
City guides
-
Charlotte, North Carolina
First city guide. Built because local residents keep asking, in public, where they can get a tank refilled rather than exchanged.
More cities will be added the same way: official locators first, hours and prices only when a real source states them, and a “verify before you go” note everywhere else.
Sources
- NIST, “Liquified Petroleum Gas 20 Pound Cylinders” — 20 lb is the safe capacity; most exchange cylinders are filled and labeled to 15 lb net.
- Blue Rhino FAQ: “How much propane does Blue Rhino put in its tanks?” — net weight of 15 lbs.
- Tractor Supply, Propane Refill — sold by the gallon, no fees or minimums per their page; typical 20 lb cylinder holds approximately 4.6 gallons; refill described as a better deal than exchange.
- U-Haul propane locator results for Charlotte, NC, and the individual Charlotte location pages linked from our Charlotte guide — leftover propane is not credited on an exchange; per-gallon refill prices as posted on November 18, 2026.
- NIST Special Publication 2200-01, 2022 NCWM-NIST National Survey on 20 lb LPG Cylinders — leftover product in returned exchange cylinders.
- PHMSA, “Is Your Cylinder Safe to Fill?” (PHH50-0201-0323) — requalification intervals and condition checks. The flyer notes it is a guide to existing Hazardous Materials Regulations, not itself a regulation.